210-840-2005

Stellar Insights

Choosing a Property Manager

· By Starlight Property Management

There are many types of landlords. You might be an accidental landlord, pushed by the market or the military to rent out your home for financial reasons. You might be a weekender landlord with one or two houses you inherited or bought for extra income to travel or save. You may be a realtor building a retirement fund one rental a year who doesn't want to self-manage. You may be an investor who flips homes and keeps the rental market in your back pocket in case the market dips, or one who uses the ever-popular BRRRR method of building wealth (Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat). Or maybe you're a high-level landlord with many rental homes or multifamily units.

Whatever your situation, there are a few main things to look for in a property manager to make being a landlord a pleasant, or at least a financially responsible and profitable, experience. Here are the characteristics and policies to look for when choosing a property manager.

Communication

A smart property manager knows that communication is key for tenants and landlords, and that most issues come from a lack of it. If a tenant submits a service request and doesn't get a response, that can create liability. If an owner hasn't been paid and can't get a clear answer about where their money is, that creates trust issues.

You want a property manager who is accessible, responds to these concerns, and communicates clearly about expenses and expectations on both sides of the rental from day one.

Relationships

The best rental experiences are built on relationships. Tenants want to feel like they matter. Finding a home, going through credit screening and background checks, and then paying thousands of dollars to move in is already stressful. After jumping through all of those hoops, tenants don't want their service requests ignored or to feel like their property manager is the enemy, just waiting to send a notice or a fine.

Without renters, landlords would be in big trouble, and a good renter is worth their weight in peace of mind and profit! A property manager who builds a good relationship with your qualified renter can mean lower turnover costs, a larger rent increase at renewal time, and peace of mind that your investment is in respectful hands.

Cat-Like Reflexes

Property management is not for the faint of heart. Choose a property manager who is a problem solver with a quick response time, to keep liability risk as low as possible for you and your property. When you deal with the public, brand-new situations come up all the time. If your property manager could hypothetically fall off a building and land on their feet, chances are good they're the one for you.

Knowledge

Your property manager should be a jack of all trades. To rent a home and keep a good renter in it, they need to know how to:

  • Assess the market for the best rental rate
  • Advertise and market the property for maximum exposure and less vacancy loss
  • Screen tenants in a way that doesn't make them feel like criminals and keeps them excited about moving in
  • Recognize which repairs are emergencies and which can wait
  • Spot when a vendor is trying to take advantage of you
  • Find reliable, affordable vendors who get the job done right the first time

That's in addition to move-out procedures, local laws, and knowing what to do if a renter doesn't follow the lease or pay the rent.

A Good Attitude

A property manager with a good attitude, and even a sense of humor, can make a real difference in how much you enjoy being a landlord. Tenants and vendors alike respond well to a good attitude, which can mean better tenants, better prices and more efficiency in getting things done.

A property manager with a good attitude is also more approachable. Tenants are more likely to share problems or concerns if they believe solutions are available, rather than feeling judged or shamed when issues come up.

Conflict Resolution

Along with a good attitude, you want someone who is skilled at managing conflict. Things don't always go as planned, and when they don't, the right person can find a solution, get both parties on board, keep the train moving and prevent a communication breakdown.

It's important to have a property manager who isn't afraid of conflict and will face it when needed. You want someone like mom: kind when you're doing what you should, but not afraid to tell you what's what, and what the consequences are if you aren't.

In Summary

Finding the right person for the job takes some effort, but the results are worth it! The right property manager will pay for themselves over time in knowledge and increased profit year after year, while the wrong fit will drive away good tenants and lead to declining property condition and profit.

Looking for a property manager in Texas? Learn about our services or get a free rental analysis.

← Back to Stellar Insights

Ready for stress-free property management?

Talk with a Starlight portfolio manager in your area. No fees until your home is rented.