210-840-2005

Stellar Insights

Should I Rent or Sell My House in Texas?

· By Starlight Property Management

Whether you're relocating for work, receiving military orders, upgrading to a bigger home or inheriting a property, you'll eventually face the question: should I sell this house, or keep it and rent it out?

There's no single right answer, but there is a right way to decide. Here are the factors that matter most for Texas homeowners.

1. Will the rent cover the costs?

Start with the numbers. List every monthly cost of keeping the home:

  • Mortgage payment (principal and interest)
  • Property taxes, which are often the biggest surprise in Texas
  • Landlord insurance (it usually costs more than a homeowner's policy)
  • HOA dues, if any
  • A maintenance reserve (many owners set aside 5% to 10% of the rent)
  • Property management fees, if you won't self-manage
  • An allowance for vacancy between tenants

Then compare that total to a realistic rent. Not what you hope to get, but what similar homes nearby are actually renting for. Our free rental analysis gives you that number, and our rent vs. sell calculator lets you compare both paths side by side.

If the rent covers your costs with room to spare, renting can build wealth through cash flow, loan paydown and appreciation. If it doesn't, you'll be paying out of pocket every month to hold the property.

2. Plan for higher property taxes

Texas has no state income tax, so property taxes do a lot of the work, and they hit rental owners harder. When a home is your principal residence, you can claim the homestead exemption, which lowers your taxable value and caps how much the taxable value of your home can rise each year.

Once you move out and the home is no longer your principal residence, you'll generally lose that exemption, and your tax bill can go up noticeably. Check with your county appraisal district and build the higher number into your budget.

3. Watch the capital gains clock

Under federal tax rules, homeowners who sell a home they've owned and lived in for at least two of the last five years can usually exclude a large portion of the gain from income tax: up to $250,000 for single filers and $500,000 for married couples filing jointly.

That means if you rent out your former home for more than about three years, you may lose that exclusion when you finally sell. Some owners rent for a year or two to see how it goes, then decide while the exclusion is still available. Rules have exceptions and details, so talk with a CPA before you decide.

4. Think about the market and your timeline

  • Do you plan to come back? Military families and those on temporary assignments often rent their home so it's waiting for them.
  • Is the market favoring sellers right now? If homes in your area are selling quickly at strong prices, selling may lock in a good result.
  • Is rental demand strong? Areas near major employers, bases, universities and medical centers tend to rent quickly.
  • What would you do with the cash? Selling frees up equity for a down payment, paying down debt or other investments.

5. Be honest about the landlord life

Owning a rental means late-night repair calls, tenant screening, fair housing compliance, deposit rules and the occasional difficult situation. Some owners enjoy it. Many would rather have someone else handle it. A good property manager turns a rental into a much more passive investment, especially if you're moving out of the area.

The bottom line

Renting often makes sense when the rent covers your costs, you want long-term appreciation, or you may come back someday. Selling often makes sense when the numbers don't work, you need the equity, or your capital gains exclusion is about to expire.

We can help either way

Starlight manages rental homes across Texas, and our real estate partners at BK Real Estate help owners sell. That means we'll give you an honest answer, not just the one that earns us a fee. Start with a free rental analysis or find out what your home is worth, and we'll walk you through both options.

← Back to Stellar Insights

Ready for stress-free property management?

Talk with a Starlight portfolio manager in your area. No fees until your home is rented.