Owner Tools
Rent vs. Sell Calculator
Compare the cash you would walk away with if you sell today against the equity and rental cash flow you could build by keeping the home as a rental.
Year by year
How the numbers build
| Year | Rent collected | Mortgage paid | Other costs | Net cash flow | Home value | Equity after selling costs | Total if you rent | Total if you sell now |
|---|
How to read this
- Sell now: net proceeds are the sale price minus selling costs and your mortgage payoff. To compare fairly, the calculator assumes you invest that cash at the return you enter.
- Rent, then sell: the home grows at your appreciation rate while the mortgage is paid down. At the end, equity is the future value minus selling costs and the remaining balance. Cumulative cash flow is every year's rent collected, minus vacancy, management, maintenance, taxes, insurance, HOA and mortgage payments, plus your upfront costs in year one.
- Taxes and insurance rise with the home's value. Cash flow is added up, not reinvested, so the rental side is slightly conservative.
- Not included: income taxes on rental profit, depreciation, capital gains taxes and the primary-residence exclusion. If this has been your home, selling within the IRS ownership-and-use window may let you exclude much of the gain, which can tip the decision. Ask your CPA.
- Leasing costs: Starlight's leasing fee is 50% of one month's rent in most of Texas and 75% in DFW, Houston and Austin. Management is 10% of rent collected, and nothing while vacant. See pricing.
Disclaimer: These are estimates for illustration only, not financial, tax or legal advice. Home values, rents and expenses can move differently than assumed. Consult a qualified tax or financial professional before deciding to rent or sell.
Talk it through
Get real numbers for your home
Thinking of renting it out? Our local portfolio managers can tell you what your home would likely rent for and what expenses to plan for, with a free, no-obligation rental analysis.
Leaning toward selling? Starlight's real estate sales are handled through BK Real Estate, who can give you a market value estimate and help you list.
Free Rental Analysis
Ready for stress-free property management?
Talk with a Starlight portfolio manager in your area. No fees until your home is rented.